In this era of Moneyball for baseball and now Moneyball for basketball, it continues to amaze me that the average fan thinks they know more about which teams and players are good than the data...Folks, the data does not lie. While not foolproof by any stretch, data analysis will typically get you closer than the truth than attempting to watch every game played in the course of a season...which, by the way, is not really possible.
So here goes...one dude's attempt...
Criteria #1: OOC schedule and wins...
Now, admittedly, not all OOC wins are created equal, so let's take a look at Big 6 vs. Big 6...ACC, Big 10, Big 12, Big East, Pac 10 and SEC...how did teams from these 'power' conferences fair against each other this year?
ACC: 27-18 (.600)
Big 10: 19-18 (.514)
Big 12: 19-21 (.475)
Big E: 22-21 (.512)
Pac 10: 14-17 (.452)
SEC: 15-21 (.417)
Directionally, this is probably pretty close to the consensus, if you had to group Top 3 and Bottom 3. However, it is fairly clear that the ACC fared far better than the rest of the conferences.
Argument #2: Depth...
Ok, here is where the 'experts' generally give the Big East the nod. Tell me if you've heard this before "Every night out in the ACC/Big East it's a test, babeee...an absolute test. There are no easy ones, babee"...Well, that is my argument--I think the Big East gets a few gimmes and the ACC teams really don't. Let's examine using RPI (I won't unleash my computer rankings at this point--that is on the way, but for these purposes, let's a use something a bit more 'mainstream').
Let's not spend too much time at the top...I'd say Pitt, UConn and UNC are all Tier 1. Duke, Clemson, Wake, Florida State, Louisville, West Virginia, Villanova, Marquette and Syracuse are very similar. Don't think it is a strech to group Miami, Virginia Tech, BC, Cincy, and Georgetown together. Next is Maryland, Providence and Notre Dame, then UVa, NC St. and Seton Hall.
That leaves Georgia Tech from the ACC and St. John's, South Florida, Rutgers and DePaul--what do these teams have in common? They all have RPI's greater than 136.
St. John's #136
South Florida #153
Georgia Tech #167
Rutgers #168
DePual #191
Clearly, there is a separation in both leagues between the teams that are competitive and those that are of little to no threat to beat the top teams in the league. Where is Virginia, you ask? Well, with an RPI of 90, which is 1 spot better than NC St. and only 3 spots behind Seton Hall, I don't think it is unfair to exclude them. After all, UVa does sport the #2 overall SOS according to the RPI with 8 losses to Top 25 teams.
Why does this matter? Let's examine the total wins the top 50% of each league has amassed against these inferior clubs.
First, the ACC (Top 6 teams = UNC, Duke, Clemson, Wake, Florida St, Miami).
Total record vs. Georgia Tech: 3-1
Next, the Big East (Top 8 teams = UConn, Pitt, 'Nova, WVU, Louisville, 'Cuse, Marquette, G'town)
Total record vs. Bottom 4: 25-1
You want to read that again? Out of the 69 conferences wins amassed by these teams, 25 of them have been against the bottom dwellers--36%. And if you want to try and make the argument that it's because the top 8 Big East teams are that good, please don't...the OOC record vs. the Big 6 conferences is 0-9, including 0-5 vs. the ACC. Simply put, these 4 teams are not high caliber teams and would struggle winning a LOT of conferences, let alone competing in the Big East.
For argument's sake, let's toss UVa into the mix for the ACC.
Total record vs. Bottom 2: 12-2
Out of 46 total wins for the top 6 ACC teams, 12 were against the bottom--26% (only 3 against a team outside the top 100 in RPI).
It is a monumental difference...on average, Big East teams will play 25% of their games against the 'bad' teams, while the ACC teams will generally only play around 18% of the 'bad' teams...and that includes UVa, a team that doesn't really classify as 'bad' according to the data.
Comments are always welcome (as if there is anyone reading...lol). Enjoy and let the debate rage.
--RB
